Skip to main content

Rules I Break (Part 2 of 2)

            


            In last week's blog, we addressed a few ground rules often taught to beginning cellists along with some instances in which those rules should be broken. The right hand similarly has some rules that need to be broken in certain instances. Today we will address two of those.

Straight Bow

            Playing with a straight bow is crucial for a clear, consistent tone free of scratch in the sound, but if you watch great cellists, you will notice that they do not play with a straight bow 100% of the time. Why is this? As helpful as a straight bow can be for producing a homogeneous tone throughout the whole bow stroke, a straight bow is not necessarily the best way to produce a broad range of tone colors. Watch this video in which Thomas Mesa demonstrates the 10 bow lanes on the cello and when he plays with a crooked bow on purpose.



            In addition to the excellent advice Mr. Mesa gives, angling the bow helps move the bow across the bow lanes. This exercise that I learned from Natasha Brofsky entitled "The Snake" is helpful in exaggerating the usefulness of the slanted bow. You can use this exercise to work on either keeping a consistent tone with a slanted bow or allow the change in your bow's contact point to vary the tone.

Bent Right Thumb

            Many string players liken the fingers on the bow to shock absorbers, a very accurate and relatable analogy. Shock absorbers must be free to move in order to be effective. Similarly our fingers must be free to adjust and not be fixed in one rigid position. In other words, there is no one correct position for the thumb.

Like many others, I was first taught that a bent thumb was more relaxed and that a straight thumb was more tense. After all, just feel the thumb muscle with the thumb bent versus straight and notice how the muscle feels more supple and soft when the thumb is bent. 

However, music does not require a constant state of release but rather a fluid balance between tension and release. As a broad over-generalization, the thumb should be more bent at the frog than at the tip. Many of us need all the help we can get to reach all the way to the tip, and straightening the thumb moves us that much closer to the end of the bow. 

See this previous blog post for more suggestions on reaching the tip. The role of the thumb is too detailed to cover in one blog post, but suffice it to say that a flexible thumb is more desirable than a thumb conforming to a single position. 

What have your discovered about the right hand that is different than what you were first taught? Leave your ideas in the comments below.

Visit my youtube channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UClM371Cwtge1QLxIj2VLKWA?view_as=subscriber

Visit my facebook page here: www.facebook.com/simmonsmusic 

©2020 by Jonathan Simmons. All rights reserved. 


 

 



Labels

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Emanuel Moór - Composer Profile and Cello Sonata, No. 2 in G Major, Op. 55

           The following post is adapted from the notes of a lecture recital cancelled due to COVID-19. I am happy to now share with you this research regarding a neglected composer and his life's work.   Emanuel Moór Self Portrait Hungarian composer Emanuel Moór (1863-1931) was the son of Jewish cantor Raphael Moór. Found at an early age to have an aptitude for music, the young Emanuel studied piano, organ and composition. His notable teachers included Franz Liszt on piano, Robert Volkman for composition, as well as a few composition lessons with Johannes Brahms. As a boy he performed in both Europe and America to much acclaim. However, today he is remembered mostly as an inventor. Moór invented a new design for both violin and piano. His piano featured two keyboards, similar in concept to the multiple manuals of a pipe organ or harpsichord, yet still with one set of hammers and one set of strings. Steinway produced a single prototype which is ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Surviving Life as a Small-Handed, Short-Armed Cellist

              String players come in all shapes and sizes. Some violinists look like they were born to play the double bass, and other people like me seem so small that they should be banished to a partial size instrument into adulthood. If you are in the second category, I feel your pain. Although we must come up with solutions to the unique technical challenges that we face, playing a large instrument is not impossible even for petite individuals. As a side note, this is not to say that adults should never consider a 3/4 or 7/8 size instrument or a shorter bow in some cases. Some physiques may require this. Be sure to seek your teacher's advice on instrument setup (endpin length, angle of the instrument, etc.). Likewise students who are not yet fully grown should seek their teacher’s input before moving to a size that may be uncomfortably large. In this blog I simply hope to share several ways I have found to overcome the...
4 comments
Read more

Learning Extensions Forward and Backward

                   String pedagogy tends to lump all extensions into one large animal. As cellists know however, not all extensions are created equal but rather are divided into two completely different categories of forward and backward extensions. Let us explore the similarities and differences below. Extensions             To begin, we need to set two ground rules. #1. Extensions always occur between first and second fingers in the neck positions.                Once we understand this concept, extensions become more manageable. All the fingers remain half-steps apart from adjacent fingers with the exception of the first finger that will be a whole-step away from second finger. No need to worry about your short pinky not reaching forward far enough on its own. Rather allow the movement of the second finger to push the ot...
3 comments
Read more